Decision record archive
Science & Society records.
AI debates on science, technology, and society: pandemics, quantum computing, Mars colonization, and AI ethics.
13 records
All records Science & Society Is it ethical to use AI to write personal messages? Yes, using AI to write personal messages is ethical when it helps you say what you genuinely mean. It becomes unethical when it fabricates care, hides responsibility, uploads... Science & Society Why is antibiotic resistance being called a bigger threat than climate change? Antibiotic resistance is not objectively a bigger threat than climate change—the comparison itself is a misleading distraction. AMR will cause roughly 1.5 million deaths... Science & Society What's the actual state of Alzheimer's research and are we close to a breakthrough? No, we are not close to a breakthrough — and the question itself is built on a flawed premise. The two approved drugs (Leqembi, Kisunba) clear amyloid plaques but only slow... Science & Society Is CRISPR gene editing going to cure genetic diseases or create designer babies first? CRISPR will cure genetic diseases first — in fact, it already has. The FDA approved Casgevy in December 2023, a CRISPR therapy for sickle cell disease, establishing the... Science & Society What happens to a society where 30% of men under 30 are unemployed and unmarried? A society with 30% of young men unemployed and unmarried doesn't collapse — it calcifies. Neighborhood commercial corridors hollow out as household formation disappears, birth... Science & Society What happens to global agriculture if pollinator populations collapse by 50%? A 50% pollinator collapse will not cause mass starvation, but it will trigger cascading financial and trade failures that strand food where it exists and devastate nutrition... Science & Society Is nuclear fusion actually 10 years away this time or is it always 10 years away? Fusion is still decades away from commercial deployment, and the pattern of delays shows no sign of breaking. The National Ignition Facility achieved scientific breakeven in... Science & Society Which one results in a better framework of morals and ethics, Physicalist vs Non-Physicalist theories of consciousness? Neither framework gives you what you need—a complete system that derives binding moral obligations from first principles—but physicalism provides the only testable, improvable... Science & Society What happens when AI can generate evidence that's indistinguishable from real photos and video in court? The only viable path to preserving judicial integrity is mandatory pre-trial forensic authentication; relying on human intuition or shifting burdens of proof invites... Science & Society Is quantum computing going to break all encryption and what happens to banking? Yes, quantum computing will break current public-key encryption used to secure banking handshakes, forcing an immediate shift to post-quantum cryptography while simultaneously... Science & Society Is another pandemic inevitable and are we any more prepared than in 2020? Another pandemic is inevitable due to biological uncertainty, yet we are significantly less prepared than in 2020 because our readiness hinges on fragile geopolitical alliances... Science & Society IBM just announced a 4,000-qubit quantum computer that can break RSA-2048 in hours. Our entire infrastructure, 240 million customer accounts, SWIFT integrations, regulatory compliance systems, runs on RSA and ECC encryption. NIST has published post-quantum standards but migration will take 3-5 years. We might not have 3 years. What's our strategy? Begin the cryptographic asset inventory in Q3 2026 under regulatory compliance justification, but defer production quantum-safe deployments until 2028 or until peer-reviewed... Science & Society Should humanity try to colonize Mars in the next 50 years? Humanity should pursue Mars colonization over the next 50 years, but only under strict conditions — and those conditions matter more than the goal itself. The debate revealed...
Bring Manwe a decision in this category.
Use the archive as proof of the process, then start a private run in the web app when you need a decision record for your own situation.